Catch block not firing all statements

My goal is to test my function: fetchStats

Expected Results: It console.logs the error and a failure message. and sets _isFetching to false.

Actual Results: The error is caught but console.logs not fired and isFetching is not set.

Code below:

fetchStats:

fetchStats() {
    this._isFetching = true;
    // fetch stats after building url and replacing invalid characters
    return new Promise(async (resolve, reject) => {
      await API.fetchStats(this.rsn)
        .then(jres => {
          this.skills = jres.main.skills;
          this._isFetching = false;
          resolve('success');
        })
        .catch(err => {
          console.log(err);
          console.log('error retreiving stats');
          this._isFetching = false;
          reject('Failed to retreive stats');
        })
        .finally(() => {
          this._isFetching = false;
        });
    });
  }

The test:

it("catches thrown errors", () => {
      this.apiFetchStats.throws(new Error());
      const player = Player.fromJSON(
        JSON.stringify({
          rsn: 'rsn',
          skills: {
            overall: { level: 2000 },
            attack: { attack: {} },
            defence: { defence: {} },
         },  
        })  
      );
      sinon.spy(console, "log");
      player.fetchStats();
      expect(this.apiFetchStats).to.be.calledOnce;
      expect(this.apiFetchStats).to.have.thrown();
      expect(console.log).to.have.been.calledTwice;
      expect(player.isFetching()).to.be.false;
      console.log.restore();
    });
  });

The first two expects pass fine, signalling that it has been called and did throw so it should be in catch block but console.log was not called and isFetching was not set. Does anyone have an idea on what is going wrong?